V-Strom Riders International
10/22/14 2139 Hours


Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Login with username, password and session length
News: For login problems please contact admin - motorcycle@vssupportqueue.com
Advanced search  
  Pages: 1 |   Go to Bottom of page
EMAIL THIS TOPIC | PRINT
Author Topic: Carbolex versus Cordura  (Read 4686 times)
0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.
JoeInKS
Guest
« on: 08/21/08 0315 Hours »
| All unread Move to top Move to bottom  


Just trying to figure out all the hype on materials.......

If anyone has any information on how Carbolex compares to Cordura and to the stuff that Joe Rocket uses. etc.  I saw the information on Motoport's site concerning some materials versus the Kevlar that they use but would love to get a feeling for how good the other stuff out there is.

Thanks for the help.
Logged

Donunder
***
08/19/06 0556 Hours
Posts: 381
DL 1000 K6
Brisbane, Australia.
Offline
« REPLY #1 on: 08/26/08 1509 Hours »
| All unread Move to top Move to bottom  

The BMW guys think the Motoport stuff is right up there with the branded BM gear.
It's supposedly more comfortable than Aerostich and Olympia. (Just repeating their comments here, no personal experience.)
You will need two jackets, despite what the manufacturers tell you. One mesh for the warmer months, and one close-weave cordura (warmer and water resistant) for winter. Textile technology has advanced so much in recent times that some riders question whether leather is really necessary-- but that's what they race with, so...??
In any case, you need something NOW. Don't be riding in your old windbreaker while you're messing about deciding. You've obviously done some research and seen what others on the forum have had to say. Make a decision, buy the best your budget allows, and get some protection happening pronto! And don't skimp on gloves quality either.
Logged

Don.
amx304
***
06/27/07 2301 Hours
Posts: 116
Omawhere?
Offline
« REPLY #2 on: 08/27/08 2341 Hours »
| All unread Move to top Move to bottom  

+1 one Olympia stuff. I have a jacket, pants and gloves that are great.

Different manufacturers have different names for their own brand of skid protection material. Motoport would like everyone to believe their gear is the only thing you should wear. They do make good gear. But it's terribly expensive. Cordura has been around for a while and it's protective properties are well known. I decided to stick with a known quantity. I bought the Olympia gear made from Cordura. The Olympia gear also has CE approved armor...including the back.

You can come pretty close to a 4 season jacket. My Bushwacker does a pretty good job in the cold. With a heated liner underneath, it's very comfy to ride down to about 40.
Logged
Bstrom Patterson
Guest
« REPLY #3 on: 08/28/08 0039 Hours »
| All unread Move to top Move to bottom  

I've tried to get details on that material and others - the makers are not too willing to spell out what's what. In general, they are higher performance nylon weaves that offer higher abrasion protection, so check the denier thread count as a comparison.  Armor is equally important, so check for CE vs. other types, leather reinforcement, etc. for the best value.

I've gone with Cortech's GX Sport and GX Air Mesh jackets - like them both very much for fit, finish and price.
Logged
JoeInKS
Guest
« REPLY #4 on: 08/28/08 0225 Hours »
| All unread Move to top Move to bottom  


Thanks for the replies.  What had me a little worried is the seemingly larger concern within the US for marketing than for actual safety of the equipment.  The European standards seem to be more stringent and more emphasis is placed on safety. For instance, the German motorcycle standards supposedly being the best.

I like the Olympia stuff so I think that I'll order something soon.  Tourmaster and Cortech seem also to be of good quality with respect to Denier rating and armor.

Just so annoying that there's more concern seemingly in anything other than safety first.

Logged
Oxblood
**
06/25/08 2335 Hours
Posts: 10
Vancouver, Canada
Offline
« REPLY #5 on: 10/03/08 2206 Hours »
| All unread Move to top Move to bottom  

Fieldsheer has some information regarding Carbolex on their web site:

http://www.fieldsheer.com/2009site/ff/Material.html

The describe it as a high performance polyester that has 90% the abrasion resistance of leather. They state that they submitted the fabric for independent testing under standardized measurements, and have a graph showing mean cycles to failure.

There are a LOT of synthetic textiles out there. Some people claim polyester is inferior, without recognizing that there are many different types of polyester fabrics. Given what they state on their tech data page above, and the fact they are still in business and have not been sued into the ground should suggest their gear is sound.
Logged
motoman
*
07/11/11 0408 Hours
Posts: 2
Offline
« REPLY #6 on: 02/23/12 1849 Hours »
| All unread Move to top Move to bottom  

Update to Fieldsheer link above.  Seems to be the Final Word.

I still can't help thinking that Carbolex is just a cheaper alternative to Cordura.  I loves me some 1600D Cordura!

http://www.fieldsheer.com/site2010/ff/Material.html
Logged
Pages: 1 |  Go to Top of page
EMAIL THIS TOPIC | PRINT
Jump to:  

 B l a c k - R a i n V.2 by C r i p ~ Powered by SMF 1.1.18 | SMF © 2013, Simple Machines MySQL | PHP | XHTML | CSS   
Copyright V-Strom Riders International 2003-2013